It's very hard for anyone to believe that  there was any kind of love between Jodhaa and Akbar as theirs was just a  political union. But Ashutosh has successfully implanted some "love" components  and that too quite seamlessly in the story, which show his class. Some examples  include showing Akbar's respect towards Jodhaa's feelings and faith, and  Jodhaa's boldness and beauty true to the character of a Rajput Pricess. Both  Hrithik and Aishwarya have been excellent in their respective roles.  
Ashutosh Gowariker's brilliance is seen in  the melodious song "Khwaja Khwaja" where he has shown that Akbar is so  overwhelmed by the praise of Khwaja Moinuddin and the beats of the song that he  forces himself to dance with the other performers. 
The picturization of another song  "Azeem-o-shan.." is truly superb. The performance of the artists is very  organized and well directed. 
So far so good but there are few points  I'd like to raise which seem hard to digest. 
1. It's been shown that Akbar's sister was  not pleased with the concept of the "muslim" Akbar marrying the "hindu" Jodhaa.  We all know that the Mughals invaded India with their huge armies, and they had  no business bringing women with them all the way from Persia, Afghanistan etc.  So in most of the cases the only option, which they enjoyed a lot, was to marry  hindu girls (I strongly believe that this was precisely the reason why people  used to marry off their daughters at the age of as low as 10-11). So the concern  expressed by Akbar's sister in the movie, and in general, doesn't make sense.  
2. By no stretch of imagination one could  think that the prayers sung by Jodhaa in the janaankhana were louder enough to be heard  in the durbar of Akbar. 
3. Akbar's dialogue "Hum Hindustan ko galat hathon me nahi jaane  dengey", just before a war, seems devoid of logic. Just the fact that  Akbar was born in a Rajput Fortress doesn't make him a Hindustani, as we all  know that the Mughals were invaders. 
Overall this movie is certainly worth  watching. I've always been an admirer of Ashutosh Gowariker. I consider his  "Swades" above anything else produced during the last decade.  
I'd love to see a grand movie on  Chhatrapati Shivaji from the same director.
6 comments:
Good job Abhijeet...
Looks cool....
I must watch the movie now..
Hi,
Very critical examination of movie...i haven't seen the movie but liked the socio-political linkages you have analysed and exibited in the blog.
liked the analytics.
Dhobya !!!! Sahi re!!
Certain hindi movies one has to watch without much logic....so just chill dhobya....vaise dekha to Hritik is not at all graceful in Akbar's role..
good review dhobya..
regarding ur 1st point, concerns raised by AKBAR's relative bout his hindu wife was bout making her Maharani.[Not treating her like just one of the lady in Harem]. Political marriages
took place before AKBAR also but only AKBAR gave religious freedom to his wife...Many historical text mentioned role of his Hindu wife in evolution of AKBAR'S socio-political outlook- called as 'SULH-KUL'.
Hi Dhobya.. I don't agree with your point#1 in which you have mentioned that the Sister of Akbar was against the marriage. I watched the movie last weekend and I am sure there is no scene which tells that Akbar's sis was against the marriage.
Watch the movie again and update the blog.
Post a Comment